- Business
- Childbirth & Education
- Legal Formalities
- Motoring
- Other
- Pensions & Benefits
- Property & Accommodation
- Taxes
- Airports and Airlines Spain
- Paramount Theme Park Murcia Spain
- Corvera International Airport Murcia Spain
- Join us for Tea on the Terrace
- When Expat Eyes Are Smiling
- Meet Wincham at The Homes, Gardens & Lifestyle Show, Calpe
- QROPS 2014
- Spain Increases IHT in Valencia & Murcia
- Removals to Spain v Exports from Spain
- The Charm of Seville
- Gibraltar Relations
- Retiro Park : Madrid
- Community Insurance in Spain
- Calendar Girls
- Considerations when Insuring your Boat in Spain
- QROPS – HMRC Introduces changes that create havoc in the market place
- QROPS – All Change From April 2012
- Liva & Laia : 15th November
In order to surprise us just before Christmas the Government published a discussion document on December 13th titled “Early Access to Pensions Savings“. One can only imagine that this has at least in part been prompted by the far from level playing field that has arisen since QROPS were introduced back in 2006. After all, when utilising QROPS the long term non-UK resident is able to access up to 100% of his UK pension fund as a lump sum, then it surely makes sense for well controlled accessibility to be available for UK residents as well.
The main driver for the discussion document is however a commitment in the Coalition agreement to explore the subject of early access – there is no commitment to introduce it. Actually, if I were a betting man I can see this one destined for the long grass.
The HMT publication is one which seeks evidence and research from interested parties. It does not contain proposals as such but puts forward ideas for interested parties to consider and a set of questions to be answered.
Implementation of any early access is therefore a long way off, if ever. It would be hard to envisage anything happening before April 2012. The HMT document if anything sets out reasons why early access should not be introduced - for example it states that .... “early access to private pension savings may not be an effective policy to help the majority of individuals facing financial hardship.” Simply because those in financial hardship tend to have little by way of pension savings – “individuals or households with no liquid savings to fall back on in the event of hardship, or a life event requiring access to a capital lump sum, are also more likely to have limited or no pension savings”.
Four possible models for early access are presented :
1.) A loan model allowing individuals to borrow from their pension fund
2.) A permanent withdrawal model, allowing access to funds without repayment obligations – possibly in limited circumstances, such as in cases of hardship
3.) Early access to the 25 per cent tax-free lump sum currently available from age 55
4.) A feeder-fund model, creating a more flexible savings product linking liquid savings products, such as ISAs, and pension savings together into a single account
However, HMT say of the loan model “The Government is however wary of the potential complexity of incorporating a loan model into the UK pensions tax framework”.
Permanent withdrawal is considered in the context of the New Zealand model (the usual destination for permanent withdrawals for long term expats through a QROPS), but with a limitation based on proven financial hardship. Again one senses a luke warm attitude on the part of HMT - “permanent withdrawals create a potential tension within the UK’s ‘EET’ pensions tax framework”, and the issues associated for final salary schemes in particular are highlighted.
Regarding early access to the 25% lump sum, HMT are concerned that controls would need to be introduced “since the 25 per cent tax-free lump sum could be recycled into further tax-relieved pension saving”. Perish the thought !
All told therefore a reading of the discussion document leads to the possible conclusion that this has been produced primarily because of a commitment under the Coalition agreement to do so. I do not sense any great appetite for change.
However, so far as the long term expat is concerned a huge amount of flexibility is and remains available.
Some advocate that this flexibility will change (although there is no sign of it), however it would be hard on the one hand for HMT to be looking (albeit with limited enthusiasm) at the possibility of earlier access to pension funds for UK residents if at the same time there were changes to the QROPS rules which went in the opposite direction.
The Pensions Reciprocation Plan (PRP) however gives this greater flexibility and it delivers it now. But not through early access to the members own fund. The PRP instead is focussed on maximising the value of the members pension rights (current and future) whilst at the same time allowing the member through pensions reciprocation to avail himself of a lump sum.
- QROPS – HMRC Introduces changes that create havoc in the market place
- The Economy : What can we look forward to in 2012 ?
- Beyond the tipping point - where next ?
- New Zealand QROPS - good news for all concerned
- Pensions and Politicians
- Changes re New Zealand QROPS - Things are becoming clearer
- QROPS Jurisdictions in Focus : A Round-Up
- QROPS Jurisdiction in Focus : Isle of Man
- QROPS for the UK Expat in Spain
- Could this happen to your UK pension fund?
- Should I Pay Voluntary National Insurance Contributions to the UK ?
- How to claim a widow or widowers pension in Spain
- Bereavement & Funerals in Spain
- How to Choose a Dentist in Spain
- Claiming Unemployment Benefits in Spain
- Claiming a Spanish or UK Pension in Spain
- How to Apply for Free State Healthcare in Spain
- Claiming Spanish Benefits in Spain
- Can I claim UK benefits if I am widowed in Spain ?
- What exactly is 'QROPS' ?
- Common-Law Partnerships In Spain - 'Pareja de Hecho'
- Transfering your UK National Insurance Contributions to Spain
- QROPS – All Change From April 2012
- QROPS : Stop press - major changes on their way!
- Do you have a UK pension fund? How secure is it?
- Quantitative Easing - good or bad (or both) for your UK Pension Fund?
- Did Your Pension Fund Fall By 15 Percent in August ?
- New Zealand QROPS : Only Available For A Further 12 Months ?
- QROPS Jurisdictions in Focus : New Zealand
- QROPS Jurisdiction in Focus : Guernsey
- QROPS - the realities of giving and receiving advice
- QROPs - Choice of adviser and choice of jurisdiction
- Why not spring clean your pension ?
- New Zealand QROPS - some of our FAQ's
- Access Your UK Pension Fund Before It Falls In Value !